L1: the integrity check reads the scroll (tablet 38)

L1Reader.verify_integrity/0 read the hash stored in integrity.sha256
and compared that string with the hash compiled into the module. It
never opened a verse. On that comparison of a constant with its own
copy rested `l1_hash: pass`, the Cloud's "L1 corrupted — the cloud is
not visible", and Construction §1.2. A changed verse would have passed
every one of them. Every existing test passed too, because every test
asked about an untouched L1.

- L1Reader.compute_tree_hash/1: SHA-256 over every file under torah/ —
  relative path, then bytes — in the order scripts/build_l1.py hashed
  them (directories by path, files by name, plain string order). On the
  real L1 it yields the pinned 156b1d27…; for a tampered copy it yields
  the same hash the Python implementation does.
- VavPipeline.L1Integrity (new, supervised): reads and hashes the scroll
  when the pipeline starts (~0.9 s in the image) and again every ten
  minutes; logs and signals the assembly when the answer changes.
- verify_integrity/0 now requires BOTH: the recorded hash is the pinned
  one, AND the scroll on disk hashes to it (answered from the witness's
  last reading; computed on the spot where the witness is not running).
  Callers are unchanged — the Shema context, the health check and the
  status endpoint all inherit the real check.
- scripts/verify_l1.py: the same reading by hand. KOHEN.md and
  KOHEN_PROMPT.md used the hollow comparison as their L1 gate; they now
  run this.
- test/tablet38_l1_integrity_test.exs — 9 tests: the hash and its
  order; one byte / one added file / one rename each change it; the
  witness; and the whole path — with an altered scroll and an untouched
  integrity.sha256, verify_integrity fails, health says l1_hash: fail,
  and /peah/ask does not answer.

Specs: architecture §2.2 (which had been made to confess the hollow
check in d7520cd) and Construction §1.2 now describe the real one — and
its limit: a change is noticed within ten minutes, not at the instant.
deploy/ARCHITECTURE.md likewise. Doorpost @expected_hash 7e5286b9… →
3f6d47a0…, in this commit, with the witnessed files that moved it
(architecture, vayakhel).

Read before committing: Elixir 483/0 on seeds 0 7 42 99 191243. The
built image, run twice: on the engraved scroll — "read and matches
(928ms)", l1_hash pass, /peah/ask 200; on a copy with ONE LETTER changed
in Bereishit 1:1 and integrity.sha256 untouched — L1_INTEGRITY_FAILED,
l1_hash fail, cloud not readable, /peah/ask 503.

Not done: the Haskell side. Luchot.Firmware.l1ExpectedHash is compared
with nothing; the engine reads L1 without hashing it (that would need a
SHA-256 dependency). The engine is reached only through the pipeline,
which now gates every cycle on the real check.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>

vav_pipeline/lib/vav_pipeline/application.ex

@@ -33,6 +33,9 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.Application do
     children =
       [
         {VavPipeline.Chatzotzrot, []},
+        # Tablet 38 — reads the scroll and hashes it; everything that asks
+        # "is L1 intact?" is answered from this reading.
+        {VavPipeline.L1Integrity, []},
         {VavPipeline.AreiMiklat, []},
         {VavPipeline.EglahArufah, []},
         {VavPipeline.Bikurim, []},

vav_pipeline/lib/vav_pipeline/doorpost.ex

@@ -175,7 +175,7 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.Doorpost do
   # changes; the update is a deliberate operator commit. A bare
   # hash-update commit (without a corresponding spec change in the
   # same commit) is itself a drift signal.
-  @expected_hash "7e5286b99aaefa49c7516d3e27dae9d7e3f4fc9ae89347c92c5394685d953400"
+  @expected_hash "3f6d47a0b91ce12a1002cfe2d0a6bfe7af4fb280cd05264c87ba914d258a06fe"
 
   @doc "Return the list of files that constitute the category-grade specification."
   @spec files() :: [String.t()]

vav_pipeline/lib/vav_pipeline/l1_integrity.ex

@@ -0,0 +1,155 @@
+defmodule VavPipeline.L1Integrity do
+  @moduledoc """
+  The witness that the scroll in this vessel is the scroll that was engraved.
+
+  Broken tablet 38 (2026-10-04). `L1Reader.verify_integrity/0` read the
+  hash stored in `integrity.sha256` and compared that string with the hash
+  compiled into this module's neighbour. It never opened a verse. Two
+  copies of one constant were compared with each other, and on that
+  comparison rested `l1_hash: pass`, the Cloud's "L1 corrupted — the cloud
+  is not visible", and Construction §1.2's "if the hash does not match, the
+  system does not start." A verse could have been changed and every one of
+  them would have gone on saying *tov*.
+
+  This process reads the scroll. When it starts it hashes the whole of
+  `torah/` — every path and every byte, in the order `scripts/build_l1.py`
+  hashed them when L1 was engraved — and it does so again at an interval
+  (ten minutes unless configured). `L1Reader.verify_integrity/0` asks this
+  process what it found; the answer is a comparison of what is on disk
+  with what was pinned, not of the pin with itself.
+
+  Hashing 5,859 files takes a fraction of a second, which is too long to
+  do before every cycle and every health probe; so the cycle is answered
+  from the last reading, and the reading is never older than the interval.
+  Callers that arrive while the first reading is under way wait for it.
+
+  *Lo tosif alav v'lo tigra mimenu* — you shall not add to it and you shall
+  not take from it (Devarim 13:1). The check is how the vessel knows.
+  """
+
+  use GenServer
+  require Logger
+
+  alias VavPipeline.L1Reader
+
+  @default_interval :timer.minutes(10)
+
+  @type reading :: %{
+          status: :ok | {:error, String.t()},
+          computed: String.t() | nil,
+          expected: String.t(),
+          read_at: DateTime.t()
+        }
+
+  def start_link(opts \\ []) do
+    GenServer.start_link(__MODULE__, opts, name: Keyword.get(opts, :name, __MODULE__))
+  end
+
+  @doc "`:ok` if the scroll on disk hashes to the pinned hash, else `{:error, reason}`."
+  @spec status(GenServer.server()) :: :ok | {:error, String.t()}
+  def status(server \\ __MODULE__), do: GenServer.call(server, :status, 60_000)
+
+  @doc "The last reading in full — what was computed, what was expected, and when."
+  @spec reading(GenServer.server()) :: reading()
+  def reading(server \\ __MODULE__), do: GenServer.call(server, :reading, 60_000)
+
+  @doc "Read the scroll again now, and return what was found."
+  @spec recheck(GenServer.server()) :: :ok | {:error, String.t()}
+  def recheck(server \\ __MODULE__), do: GenServer.call(server, :recheck, 60_000)
+
+  # ------------------------------------------------------------
+  # GenServer
+  # ------------------------------------------------------------
+
+  @impl true
+  def init(opts) do
+    state = %{
+      root: Keyword.get(opts, :l1_root, L1Reader.l1_root()),
+      expected: Keyword.get(opts, :expected_hash, L1Reader.expected_hash()),
+      interval:
+        Keyword.get(
+          opts,
+          :interval,
+          Application.get_env(:vav_pipeline, :l1_rehash_interval_ms, @default_interval)
+        ),
+      reading: nil
+    }
+
+    {:ok, state, {:continue, :read}}
+  end
+
+  @impl true
+  def handle_continue(:read, state) do
+    state = read(state)
+    schedule(state)
+    {:noreply, state}
+  end
+
+  @impl true
+  def handle_info(:read, state) do
+    state = read(state)
+    schedule(state)
+    {:noreply, state}
+  end
+
+  @impl true
+  def handle_call(:status, _from, state), do: {:reply, state.reading.status, state}
+  def handle_call(:reading, _from, state), do: {:reply, state.reading, state}
+
+  def handle_call(:recheck, _from, state) do
+    state = read(state)
+    {:reply, state.reading.status, state}
+  end
+
+  defp schedule(%{interval: :never}), do: :ok
+  defp schedule(%{interval: ms}), do: Process.send_after(self(), :read, ms)
+
+  defp read(state) do
+    {micros, result} = :timer.tc(fn -> L1Reader.compute_tree_hash(state.root) end)
+    previous = state.reading && state.reading.status
+
+    {status, computed} =
+      case result do
+        {:ok, hash} when hash == state.expected ->
+          {:ok, hash}
+
+        {:ok, hash} ->
+          {{:error,
+            "L1_INTEGRITY_FAILED: the scroll on disk hashes to #{hash}, " <>
+              "expected #{state.expected}"}, hash}
+
+        {:error, reason} ->
+          {{:error, "L1_INTEGRITY_FAILED: the scroll could not be read — #{reason}"}, nil}
+      end
+
+    announce(status, previous, div(micros, 1000))
+
+    %{
+      state
+      | reading: %{
+          status: status,
+          computed: computed,
+          expected: state.expected,
+          read_at: DateTime.utc_now()
+        }
+    }
+  end
+
+  # Say it when it is first known and whenever it changes; stay quiet on
+  # the ten-minute readings that find what the last one found.
+  defp announce(status, status, _ms), do: :ok
+
+  defp announce(:ok, _previous, ms) do
+    Logger.info("L1Integrity: the scroll was read and matches its pinned hash (#{ms}ms)")
+  end
+
+  defp announce({:error, reason}, _previous, _ms) do
+    Logger.error("L1Integrity: #{reason}")
+
+    if Process.whereis(VavPipeline.Chatzotzrot) do
+      VavPipeline.Chatzotzrot.signal(:assembly_leaders, reason: reason)
+    end
+
+    :ok
+  end
+end

vav_pipeline/lib/vav_pipeline/l1_reader.ex

@@ -244,10 +244,22 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.L1Reader do
   end
 
   @doc """
-  Verify L1 integrity by checking the SHA-256 hash.
+  Verify L1 integrity: the scroll on disk must hash to the pinned hash.
 
   This is a critical check — if L1 is corrupted, the pipeline
   must halt. The specification store is inviolable.
+
+  Two things are asked, and both must hold:
+
+    1. The hash recorded beside the scroll (`integrity.sha256`) is the
+       pinned one — this L1 is the L1 this build was made for.
+    2. The scroll itself, read from disk and hashed, gives that hash
+       (`VavPipeline.L1Integrity`, which reads it at startup and again
+       every ten minutes).
+
+  Until tablet 38 only the first was asked, and the first compares a
+  recorded string with a compiled-in string: it could not notice a
+  changed verse.
   """
   @spec verify_integrity() :: :ok | {:error, String.t()}
   def verify_integrity do
@@ -258,7 +270,7 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.L1Reader do
         stored_hash = contents |> String.trim()
 
         if stored_hash == @l1_expected_hash do
-          :ok
+          verify_scroll()
         else
           {:error, "L1_INTEGRITY_FAILED: hash mismatch — stored #{stored_hash}, expected #{@l1_expected_hash}"}
         end
@@ -268,6 +280,84 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.L1Reader do
     end
   end
 
+  # What the scroll on disk actually hashes to. The supervised witness
+  # holds a recent reading; where it is not running (a bare unit test,
+  # a one-off `eval`), the scroll is read here and now.
+  defp verify_scroll do
+    if Process.whereis(VavPipeline.L1Integrity) do
+      VavPipeline.L1Integrity.status()
+    else
+      case compute_tree_hash() do
+        {:ok, @l1_expected_hash} ->
+          :ok
+
+        {:ok, other} ->
+          {:error,
+           "L1_INTEGRITY_FAILED: the scroll on disk hashes to #{other}, expected #{@l1_expected_hash}"}
+
+        {:error, reason} ->
+          {:error, "L1_INTEGRITY_FAILED: the scroll could not be read — #{reason}"}
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  @doc """
+  Hash the scroll: SHA-256 over every file under `<root>/torah`, each
+  contributing its path relative to `torah/` and then its bytes.
+
+  The order is the order `scripts/build_l1.py` (`generate_integrity_hash`)
+  used when L1 was engraved, and must stay so or the two will disagree:
+  directories in ascending order of their path, and within a directory the
+  files in ascending order of name — plain string order, so `10.json`
+  comes before `2.json`.
+  """
+  @spec compute_tree_hash(String.t()) :: {:ok, String.t()} | {:error, String.t()}
+  def compute_tree_hash(root \\ l1_root()) do
+    torah = Path.join(root, "torah")
+
+    if File.dir?(torah) do
+      digest =
+        [torah | subdirectories(torah)]
+        |> Enum.sort()
+        |> Enum.reduce(:crypto.hash_init(:sha256), fn dir, ctx ->
+          dir
+          |> File.ls!()
+          |> Enum.sort()
+          |> Enum.reduce(ctx, fn name, ctx ->
+            path = Path.join(dir, name)
+
+            if File.regular?(path) do
+              ctx
+              |> :crypto.hash_update(Path.relative_to(path, torah))
+              |> :crypto.hash_update(File.read!(path))
+            else
+              ctx
+            end
+          end)
+        end)
+        |> :crypto.hash_final()
+        |> Base.encode16(case: :lower)
+
+      {:ok, digest}
+    else
+      {:error, "#{torah} is not a directory"}
+    end
+  rescue
+    e in [File.Error] -> {:error, Exception.message(e)}
+  end
+
+  defp subdirectories(dir) do
+    dir
+    |> File.ls!()
+    |> Enum.map(&Path.join(dir, &1))
+    |> Enum.filter(&File.dir?/1)
+    |> Enum.flat_map(fn sub -> [sub | subdirectories(sub)] end)
+  end
+
+  @doc "The pinned L1 hash this build expects."
+  @spec expected_hash() :: String.t()
+  def expected_hash, do: @l1_expected_hash
+
   @doc """
   Get the root path of L1.
   """

vav_pipeline/test/tablet38_l1_integrity_test.exs

@@ -0,0 +1,247 @@
+defmodule VavPipeline.Tablet38L1IntegrityTest do
+  @moduledoc """
+  Tablet 38 (2026-10-04) — the integrity check did not check integrity.
+
+  `L1Reader.verify_integrity/0` compared the hash recorded in
+  `integrity.sha256` with the hash compiled into the module. It never read
+  a verse. Every test of it passed, because every test asked it about an
+  untouched L1 — the one question a check that checks nothing answers
+  correctly.
+
+  These tests change the scroll and ask again.
+  """
+
+  use ExUnit.Case, async: false
+
+  import Plug.Test
+  import Plug.Conn
+
+  alias VavPipeline.{HaltMonitor, L1Integrity, L1Reader, MannaLedger}
+  alias VavPipeline.BigdeiKodesh.Router
+
+  @opts Router.init([])
+
+  # ============================================================
+  # The hash itself
+  # ============================================================
+  describe "compute_tree_hash/1" do
+    test "of the real scroll is the pinned hash, and the hash build_l1.py recorded" do
+      assert {:ok, hash} = L1Reader.compute_tree_hash()
+      assert hash == L1Reader.expected_hash()
+
+      recorded = L1Reader.l1_root() |> Path.join("integrity.sha256") |> File.read!() |> String.trim()
+      assert hash == recorded
+    end
+
+    test "hashes path then bytes, directories then files, in plain string order" do
+      root = small_scroll()
+
+      # The order build_l1.py walks: the torah root's own files, then each
+      # directory by path; within a directory, names as strings — so
+      # 10.json comes before 2.json.
+      expected =
+        [
+          {"index.json", "INDEX"},
+          {"alef/1/1.json", "one"},
+          {"alef/1/10.json", "ten"},
+          {"alef/1/2.json", "two"},
+          {"alef/2/1.json", "second chapter"}
+        ]
+        |> Enum.reduce(:crypto.hash_init(:sha256), fn {rel, bytes}, ctx ->
+          ctx |> :crypto.hash_update(rel) |> :crypto.hash_update(bytes)
+        end)
+        |> :crypto.hash_final()
+        |> Base.encode16(case: :lower)
+
+      assert {:ok, ^expected} = L1Reader.compute_tree_hash(root)
+    end
+
+    test "one changed byte, one added file, one renamed file — each changes the hash" do
+      root = small_scroll()
+      {:ok, original} = L1Reader.compute_tree_hash(root)
+      verse = Path.join([root, "torah", "alef", "1", "2.json"])
+
+      File.write!(verse, "twO")
+      assert {:ok, changed} = L1Reader.compute_tree_hash(root)
+      assert changed != original
+
+      File.write!(verse, "two")
+      assert {:ok, ^original} = L1Reader.compute_tree_hash(root)
+
+      File.write!(Path.join([root, "torah", "alef", "1", "3.json"]), "an added verse")
+      assert {:ok, added} = L1Reader.compute_tree_hash(root)
+      assert added != original
+      File.rm!(Path.join([root, "torah", "alef", "1", "3.json"]))
+
+      File.rename!(verse, Path.join([root, "torah", "alef", "1", "20.json"]))
+      assert {:ok, renamed} = L1Reader.compute_tree_hash(root)
+      assert renamed != original
+    end
+
+    test "a scroll that is not there is an error, not a hash" do
+      assert {:error, reason} = L1Reader.compute_tree_hash("/nonexistent/l1")
+      assert reason =~ "not a directory"
+    end
+  end
+
+  # ============================================================
+  # The witness
+  # ============================================================
+  describe "L1Integrity" do
+    test "reads the scroll when it starts, and again when asked" do
+      root = small_scroll()
+      {:ok, pinned} = L1Reader.compute_tree_hash(root)
+
+      {:ok, pid} =
+        L1Integrity.start_link(name: :tablet38_witness, l1_root: root, expected_hash: pinned, interval: :never)
+
+      on_exit(fn -> if Process.alive?(pid), do: GenServer.stop(pid) end)
+
+      assert :ok = L1Integrity.status(:tablet38_witness)
+      assert %{computed: ^pinned, expected: ^pinned} = L1Integrity.reading(:tablet38_witness)
+
+      # Someone alters a verse. The last reading still says tov — it is a
+      # reading, not a guard — until the scroll is read again.
+      File.write!(Path.join([root, "torah", "alef", "1", "1.json"]), "0ne")
+      assert {:error, reason} = L1Integrity.recheck(:tablet38_witness)
+      assert reason =~ "L1_INTEGRITY_FAILED"
+      assert reason =~ "expected #{pinned}"
+      assert {:error, _} = L1Integrity.status(:tablet38_witness)
+
+      # Restored, it is tov again.
+      File.write!(Path.join([root, "torah", "alef", "1", "1.json"]), "one")
+      assert :ok = L1Integrity.recheck(:tablet38_witness)
+    end
+
+    test "re-reads on its own at the interval" do
+      root = small_scroll()
+      {:ok, pinned} = L1Reader.compute_tree_hash(root)
+
+      {:ok, pid} =
+        L1Integrity.start_link(name: :tablet38_periodic, l1_root: root, expected_hash: pinned, interval: 50)
+
+      on_exit(fn -> if Process.alive?(pid), do: GenServer.stop(pid) end)
+
+      assert :ok = L1Integrity.status(:tablet38_periodic)
+      File.write!(Path.join([root, "torah", "index.json"]), "INDEX, altered")
+
+      assert eventually(fn -> match?({:error, _}, L1Integrity.status(:tablet38_periodic)) end)
+    end
+  end
+
+  # ============================================================
+  # The whole path: an altered scroll stops the vessel
+  # ============================================================
+  describe "with a scroll that does not match its pin" do
+    setup do
+      if HaltMonitor.halted?(), do: HaltMonitor.resolve("tablet38 test setup")
+      MannaLedger.reset()
+      write_provision(20)
+
+      # Sanity: with the real scroll, all is well.
+      assert :ok = L1Reader.verify_integrity()
+
+      # Replace the supervised witness with one that reads an altered
+      # copy — the recorded hash file is untouched and still "matches",
+      # which is exactly the case the old check could not see.
+      root = small_scroll()
+      :ok = Supervisor.terminate_child(VavPipeline.Supervisor, L1Integrity)
+
+      {:ok, pid} =
+        L1Integrity.start_link(l1_root: root, expected_hash: L1Reader.expected_hash(), interval: :never)
+
+      on_exit(fn ->
+        if Process.alive?(pid), do: GenServer.stop(pid)
+        {:ok, _} = Supervisor.restart_child(VavPipeline.Supervisor, L1Integrity)
+        MannaLedger.reset()
+        File.rm(VavPipeline.Manna.provision_file())
+      end)
+
+      :ok
+    end
+
+    test "verify_integrity fails, though integrity.sha256 still holds the pinned hash" do
+      recorded = L1Reader.l1_root() |> Path.join("integrity.sha256") |> File.read!() |> String.trim()
+      assert recorded == L1Reader.expected_hash()
+
+      assert {:error, reason} = L1Reader.verify_integrity()
+      assert reason =~ "L1_INTEGRITY_FAILED"
+      assert reason =~ "the scroll on disk hashes to"
+    end
+
+    test "health says l1_hash: fail and the vessel is not ready" do
+      conn = conn(:get, "/kodesh/health") |> Router.call(@opts)
+      body = Jason.decode!(conn.resp_body)
+
+      assert conn.status == 503
+      assert body["checks"]["l1_hash"] == "fail"
+    end
+
+    test "no cycle runs on it — /peah/ask does not answer from an altered scroll" do
+      conn =
+        conn(:post, "/peah/ask", Jason.encode!(%{question: "בראשית ברא אלהים"}))
+        |> put_req_header("content-type", "application/json")
+        |> Router.call(@opts)
+
+      refute conn.status == 200
+      refute Map.has_key?(Jason.decode!(conn.resp_body), "answer")
+    end
+  end
+
+  # ------------------------------------------------------------
+  # Helpers
+  # ------------------------------------------------------------
+
+  defp small_scroll do
+    root = Path.join(System.tmp_dir!(), "tablet38_#{System.unique_integer([:positive])}")
+    on_exit(fn -> File.rm_rf!(root) end)
+
+    files = %{
+      "index.json" => "INDEX",
+      "alef/1/1.json" => "one",
+      "alef/1/2.json" => "two",
+      "alef/1/10.json" => "ten",
+      "alef/2/1.json" => "second chapter"
+    }
+
+    for {rel, bytes} <- files do
+      path = Path.join([root, "torah", rel])
+      File.mkdir_p!(Path.dirname(path))
+      File.write!(path, bytes)
+    end
+
+    root
+  end
+
+  defp eventually(fun, tries \\ 100) do
+    cond do
+      fun.() -> true
+      tries == 0 -> false
+      true -> Process.sleep(20) && eventually(fun, tries - 1)
+    end
+  end
+
+  defp write_provision(compute_units) do
+    today = Date.utc_today() |> Date.to_iso8601()
+    expires = DateTime.utc_now() |> DateTime.add(6 * 3600) |> DateTime.to_iso8601()
+
+    provision = %{
+      "date" => today,
+      "provision" => %{
+        "compute_units" => compute_units,
+        "memory_mb" => 512,
+        "api_calls_external" => 5,
+        "storage_delta_mb" => 2,
+        "sanhedrin_panels_max" => 2
+      },
+      "type" => "regular",
+      "expires_at" => expires,
+      "written_by" => "tablet38_test",
+      "written_at" => DateTime.utc_now() |> DateTime.to_iso8601()
+    }
+
+    path = VavPipeline.Manna.provision_file()
+    File.mkdir_p!(Path.dirname(path))
+    File.write!(path, Jason.encode!(provision))
+  end
+end