cycle: the engine is consulted on every resolved question

The Talmudic route ran only on a teiku from ki_tov, and ki_tov returns
teiku only for a root with no Hebrew — which the Shoresh Engine never
leaves. So the engine had never read a real question. Now every cycle
that resolves tov consults it with the roots it activated
(consult_engine/2, on the socket directly — never the client's stub;
an unreachable engine is reported "not consulted" and the cycle's
answer stands). A tamid probe does not consult.

The reading is said plainly (engine_reading_text/1): "Talmudic Engine
(resolved): 11 verse(s): Bereishit 1:1, …; 4 mitzvah/mitzvot:
know_hashem (1, positive), …" — the engine's own term form is no longer
pasted into a reader's answer. The verses join the sources as
references ("Bereishit 1:3", engine form beside), the L3 interpretation
carries them in torah_references with the reading in its reasoning and
processing_component "bereishit_cycle+talmudic_engine".

Proven against the engine running locally on its socket, bereishit 1:1
through VavPipeline.process/1: consulted :ok, 11 verses in the answer
and the sources, L3 torah_references 12; engine stopped → "not
consulted (Cannot connect)", answer stands, L3 component
bereishit_cycle; tamid probe → not consulted. Elixir 632/0.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>

talmudic_engine/src/interface/api.pl

@@ -45,6 +45,24 @@ process_request(request(resolve, CaseRef, Domain, Roots, Question), Response) :-
     ;   Response = response(error, no_resolution, CaseRef)
     ).
 
+%% The challenge step of the dialectic, on its own (tablet 55: the
+%% Sanhedrin's second seat asks it; until now no handler answered and
+%% the socket fell silent). Interpret, then look for a kushya against
+%% the interpretation: one stands → resolved_challenged, the kushya
+%% named; none → no_challenge, the interpretation as read.
+process_request(request(challenge, CaseRef, Domain, Roots, Question), Response) :-
+    Case = case(CaseRef, Domain, Roots, Question),
+    (   interpret(Case, Interpretation)
+    ->  (   challenge(Interpretation, Kushya)
+        ->  Response = response(ok, resolved_challenged,
+                                result(interpretation(Interpretation),
+                                       challenge(Kushya)))
+        ;   format_interpretation(Interpretation, response(ok, interpreted, Result)),
+            Response = response(ok, no_challenge, Result)
+        )
+    ;   Response = response(error, no_interpretation, CaseRef)
+    ).
+
 process_request(request(halt_check, Action), Response) :-
     format_halt_check(Action, Response).
 

talmudic_engine/src/interface/json_bridge.pl

@@ -153,11 +153,15 @@ read_coupling_term(Str, Term) :-
 %% JSON format (Construction §3.3):
 %%   { "status": "resolved", "interpretation": { ... } }
 
-%% Interpreted response
-response_to_json(response(ok, interpreted, result(ref(Ref), mitzvot(Mitzvot),
-                                                   verses(Verses), reading(Reading),
-                                                   confidence(Conf))),
+%% Interpreted response — and the same shape under the names the
+%% resolve and challenge steps give it when the reading stands
+%% (tablet 55: resolved_accepted had no clause, so a resolve that
+%% succeeded came back UNEXPECTED_RESPONSE; no_challenge is new).
+response_to_json(response(ok, Kind, result(ref(Ref), mitzvot(Mitzvot),
+                                            verses(Verses), reading(Reading),
+                                            confidence(Conf))),
                  Dict) :-
+    memberchk(Kind, [interpreted, resolved_accepted, no_challenge]),
     maplist(term_to_string, Mitzvot, MitzvotStrs),
     maplist(term_to_string, Verses, VerseStrs),
     term_to_string(Reading, ReadingStr),
@@ -171,21 +175,52 @@ response_to_json(response(ok, interpreted, result(ref(Ref), mitzvot(Mitzvot),
                                      confidence: ConfStr},
                 challenge: null}.
 
-%% Challenged response
+%% Challenged response — the interpretation's verses and mitzvot are
+%% carried, so a judge rejecting on the kushya still cites its ground.
 response_to_json(response(ok, resolved_challenged,
                           result(interpretation(Interp), challenge(Kushya))),
                  Dict) :-
+    Interp = interpretation(_Ref, Mitzvot, Verses, _Reading, _Conf, _Trace),
+    maplist(term_to_string, Mitzvot, MitzvotStrs),
+    maplist(term_to_string, Verses, VerseStrs),
     term_to_string(Interp, InterpStr),
     term_to_string(Kushya, KushyaStr),
     Dict = json{status: "challenged",
                 interpretation: json{text: InterpStr,
                                      prolog_form: InterpStr,
-                                     grounding: [],
+                                     grounding: MitzvotStrs,
+                                     verses: VerseStrs,
                                      confidence: "medium"},
                 challenge: json{kushya: KushyaStr,
                                 contradicting: "",
                                 strength: "moderate"}}.
 
+%% Synthesized resolution: both readings stand on common ground.
+response_to_json(response(ok, resolved_synthesized,
+                          result(common(Common), verses(Verses), both_sides(Both))),
+                 Dict) :-
+    maplist(term_to_string, Common, CommonStrs),
+    maplist(term_to_string, Verses, VerseStrs),
+    term_to_string(Both, BothStr),
+    Dict = json{status: "resolved",
+                interpretation: json{text: BothStr,
+                                     prolog_form: BothStr,
+                                     grounding: CommonStrs,
+                                     verses: VerseStrs,
+                                     confidence: "medium"},
+                challenge: null}.
+
+%% No interpretation possible (from resolve)
+response_to_json(response(ok, no_interpretation, result(ref(Ref))), Dict) :-
+    atom_string(Ref, RefStr),
+    Dict = json{status: "teiku",
+                interpretation: json{text: "No interpretation found",
+                                     prolog_form: RefStr,
+                                     grounding: [],
+                                     verses: [],
+                                     confidence: "low"},
+                challenge: null}.
+
 %% Teiku response
 response_to_json(response(ok, teiku, result(record(Record))), Dict) :-
     term_to_string(Record, RecordStr),

talmudic_engine/test/reasoning_test.pl

@@ -112,3 +112,52 @@ test(teiku_count_works) :-
     integer(Count).
 
 :- end_tests(teiku_module).
+
+%% ============================================================
+%% Tablet 55 — the dialectic over the wire: interpret, challenge,
+%% resolve each answer JSON a judge can vote on. Before this the
+%% engine had no "challenge" action and a resolve that succeeded came
+%% back UNEXPECTED_RESPONSE (resolved_accepted had no JSON clause).
+%% ============================================================
+
+:- use_module('../src/interface/api').
+:- use_module('../src/interface/json_bridge').
+:- use_module('../src/interface/socket_server').
+
+:- begin_tests(dialectic_over_the_wire).
+
+roots_line(Action, Line) :-
+    format(atom(Line),
+           '{"action":"~w","case":{"ref":"t55-~w","question":"q","context_roots":["bet-resh-aleph","aleph-lamed-he"]}}',
+           [Action, Action]).
+
+test(interpret_answers_resolved_with_verses, [nondet]) :-
+    roots_line(interpret, L),
+    socket_server:process_json_line(L, R),
+    get_dict(status, R, "resolved"),
+    get_dict(interpretation, R, I),
+    get_dict(verses, I, Vs), Vs \== [].
+
+test(challenge_answers_and_carries_the_ground, [nondet]) :-
+    roots_line(challenge, L),
+    socket_server:process_json_line(L, R),
+    get_dict(status, R, S),
+    memberchk(S, ["resolved", "challenged"]),
+    get_dict(interpretation, R, I),
+    get_dict(verses, I, Vs), Vs \== [].
+
+test(resolve_answers_resolved_not_unexpected, [nondet]) :-
+    roots_line(resolve, L),
+    socket_server:process_json_line(L, R),
+    \+ get_dict(error, R, _),
+    get_dict(status, R, S),
+    memberchk(S, ["resolved", "challenged", "teiku"]).
+
+test(no_roots_resolves_on_an_empty_trace, [nondet]) :-
+    socket_server:process_json_line('{"action":"interpret","case":{"ref":"t55-empty","question":"q","context_roots":[]}}', R),
+    get_dict(status, R, "resolved"),
+    get_dict(interpretation, R, I),
+    get_dict(verses, I, []),
+    get_dict(grounding, I, []).
+
+:- end_tests(dialectic_over_the_wire).

vav_pipeline/lib/vav_pipeline/bereishit_cycle.ex

@@ -63,8 +63,8 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.BereishitCycle do
   """
 
   alias VavPipeline.{Specification, CycleLog, Manna, HaltConditions,
-                      ShoreshEngineClient, TalmudicEngineClient, SanhedrinClient,
-                      Chatzotzrot}
+                      ShoreshEngineClient, TalmudicEngineClient, TalmudicEngineSocket,
+                      SanhedrinClient, Chatzotzrot}
 
   require Logger
 
@@ -308,7 +308,11 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.BereishitCycle do
     final =
       case result do
         {:ok, data} ->
-          check_halt_on_output(data)
+          # Every question is read against the engine, not only a teiku
+          # that never comes (2026-10-19: ki_tov returns teiku only on a
+          # root with no Hebrew, and the Shoresh Engine never leaves one;
+          # the Talmudic route had never been walked by a real question).
+          data |> consult_engine(context) |> check_halt_on_output()
 
         {:unresolved, data} ->
           case route_if_unresolved(data, context) do
@@ -325,6 +329,90 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.BereishitCycle do
     final
   end
 
+  # ============================================================
+  # The engine, consulted on every resolved cycle
+  # ============================================================
+
+  # Architecture §3.3: the Talmudic Engine grounds a reading in verses
+  # and mitzvot over the case's roots. The cycle's own ki_tov says the
+  # roots stand in L1; the engine says what stands on them. Called
+  # directly on the socket — never the client's stub (tablet 41): an
+  # engine that cannot be reached is reported as not consulted, and the
+  # cycle's answer stands without it. A tamid probe does not consult
+  # (the fire is checked, the engine is not loaded by the check).
+  defp consult_engine(%{probe: true} = data, _context), do: data
+
+  defp consult_engine(data, _context) do
+    roots = Map.get(data, :roots_activated, [])
+    names = roots |> Enum.map(&engine_root_name/1) |> Enum.reject(&is_nil/1)
+    case_ref = Map.get(data, :case_ref, generate_case_ref())
+
+    cond do
+      names == [] ->
+        Map.put(data, :talmudic_consulted, {:skipped, :no_roots})
+
+      Process.whereis(TalmudicEngineSocket) == nil ->
+        Map.put(data, :talmudic_consulted, {:error, :engine_socket_not_started})
+
+      true ->
+        case TalmudicEngineSocket.interpret(case_ref, %{context_roots: names, question: Map.get(data, :raw, "")}) do
+          {:ok, %{"status" => _} = reply} ->
+            Map.merge(data, %{talmudic_interpretation: reply, talmudic_consulted: :ok})
+
+          {:ok, other} ->
+            Logger.warning("BereishitCycle: engine answered an unexpected shape for #{case_ref}: #{inspect(other)}")
+            Map.put(data, :talmudic_consulted, {:error, :unexpected_reply})
+
+          {:error, reason} ->
+            Logger.warning("BereishitCycle: engine not consulted for #{case_ref}: #{inspect(reason)}")
+            Map.put(data, :talmudic_consulted, {:error, reason})
+        end
+    end
+  end
+
+  @doc """
+  The engine's reading, said plainly: how many verses and mitzvot it
+  coupled to the roots, and which. `nil` when there is no reading.
+  """
+  @spec engine_reading_text(map()) :: String.t() | nil
+  def engine_reading_text(data) do
+    case Map.get(data, :talmudic_interpretation) do
+      %{"interpretation" => interp} = reply when is_map(interp) ->
+        verses = interp |> Map.get("verses", []) |> List.wrap() |> Enum.map(&verse_ref_display/1) |> Enum.reject(&is_nil/1) |> Enum.uniq()
+        mitzvot = interp |> Map.get("grounding", []) |> List.wrap() |> Enum.map(&mitzvah_display/1) |> Enum.reject(&is_nil/1) |> Enum.uniq()
+        status = Map.get(reply, "status", "")
+
+        cond do
+          verses == [] and mitzvot == [] ->
+            "Talmudic Engine (#{status}): no verse or mitzvah is coupled to these roots."
+
+          true ->
+            v = if verses == [], do: "no verse", else: "#{length(verses)} verse(s): #{Enum.join(verses, ", ")}"
+            m = if mitzvot == [], do: "no mitzvah", else: "#{length(mitzvot)} mitzvah/mitzvot: #{Enum.join(mitzvot, ", ")}"
+            "Talmudic Engine (#{status}): #{v}; #{m}."
+        end
+
+      _ ->
+        nil
+    end
+  end
+
+  # "verse_ref(bereishit,1,1,'...')" / "verse(shemot,3,14)" → "Bereishit 1:1"
+  defp verse_ref_display(s) do
+    case Regex.run(~r/verse(?:_ref)?\((bereishit|shemot|vayikra|bamidbar|devarim)\s*,\s*(\d+)\s*,\s*(\d+)/, to_string(s)) do
+      [_, book, ch, vs] -> "#{String.capitalize(book)} #{ch}:#{vs}"
+      _ -> nil
+    end
+  end
+
+  # "mitzvah(1,positive,know_hashem,always)" → "know_hashem (1, positive)"
+  defp mitzvah_display(s) do
+    case Regex.run(~r/mitzvah\((\d+)\s*,\s*(\w+)\s*,\s*(\w+)/, to_string(s)) do
+      [_, id, kind, name] -> "#{name} (#{id}, #{kind})"
+      _ -> nil
+    end
+  end
+
   # ============================================================
   # Compose — the answer and its sources, from the context
   # ============================================================
@@ -385,15 +473,19 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.BereishitCycle do
     deliberation =
       case Map.get(data, :resolution) do
         :talmudic ->
-          text = get_in(data, [:talmudic_interpretation, "interpretation", "text"]) || ""
-          " Talmudic Engine: #{text}"
+          " " <> (engine_reading_text(data) || "Talmudic Engine resolved the case.")
 
         :sanhedrin ->
           pos = get_in(data, [:sanhedrin_decision, :majority, :position]) || ""
           " Sanhedrin majority: #{pos}"
 
         _ ->
-          ""
+          # Consulted after ki_tov (every resolved question), or not.
+          case {engine_reading_text(data), Map.get(data, :talmudic_consulted)} do
+            {text, _} when is_binary(text) -> " " <> text
+            {nil, {:error, reason}} -> " Talmudic Engine: not consulted (#{inspect(reason)})."
+            _ -> ""
+          end
       end
 
     "Roots activated in #{verse.ref}: #{Enum.join(root_lines, "; ")}." <>
@@ -426,10 +518,19 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.BereishitCycle do
       text: verse.text_hebrew
     }
 
+    # The engine's verses as references a reader can follow ("Bereishit
+    # 1:3"), the engine's own form kept beside them; the scope verse is
+    # not repeated.
     talmudic_verses =
       case get_in(data, [:talmudic_interpretation, "interpretation", "verses"]) do
-        vs when is_list(vs) -> Enum.map(vs, fn v -> %{ref: to_string(v)} end)
-        _ -> []
+        vs when is_list(vs) ->
+          vs
+          |> Enum.map(fn v -> %{ref: verse_ref_display(v) || to_string(v), engine_form: to_string(v)} end)
+          |> Enum.uniq_by(& &1.ref)
+          |> Enum.reject(&(&1.ref == verse.ref))
+
+        _ ->
+          []
       end
 
     [primary | talmudic_verses]
@@ -604,13 +705,22 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.BereishitCycle do
         {:interpretation, attrs, nil}
 
       _ ->
+        # The engine's reading, when it was consulted, rides in the record:
+        # its verses beside the scope, its text in the reasoning, and the
+        # component names both readers.
+        interp = get_in(data, [:talmudic_interpretation, "interpretation"]) || %{}
+        engine_verses = interp |> Map.get("verses", []) |> to_string_list()
+        reading = engine_reading_text(data)
+
         attrs =
           Map.merge(base, %{
-            reasoning: single_judge_reasoning(data, context),
+            reasoning:
+              if(reading, do: single_judge_reasoning(data, context) <> " " <> reading, else: single_judge_reasoning(data, context)),
+            torah_references: Enum.uniq([scope_ref | engine_verses]),
             panel_size: 1,
             vote_count_for: 1,
             vote_count_against: 0,
-            processing_component: "bereishit_cycle"
+            processing_component: if(reading, do: "bereishit_cycle+talmudic_engine", else: "bereishit_cycle")
           })
 
         {:interpretation, attrs, nil}
@@ -740,7 +850,10 @@ defmodule VavPipeline.BereishitCycle do
   @doc false
   defp route_if_unresolved(data, context) do
     roots = Map.get(data, :roots_activated, [])
-    context_roots = Enum.map(roots, & &1.shoresh)
+    # Tablet 55: the engine names roots by letter (bet_resh_aleph); the
+    # Hebrew was sent since Step 14 and never matched a verse fact, so
+    # every Talmudic interpretation was "resolved" over an empty trace.
+    context_roots = roots |> Enum.map(&engine_root_name/1) |> Enum.reject(&is_nil/1)
 
     case_ref = Map.get(data, :case_ref, generate_case_ref())