Files
bikoret/shoresh-engine/test/Spec.hs
T
Scott KarpandClaude Fable 5.1 6d3411fcfa engine: a word's root is what L1 records for it (tablet 33)
The Shoresh Engine never opened L1 to find a root. extractRoots called
every word of two or three letters a root and dropped every longer one:
את → א-ת-ה (padded with a He the text never wrote), ואת → ו-א-ת,
בכל → ב-כ-ל; ויאמר, ואהבת, אלהים → nothing. Handed all of Devarim 6:5
it found no א-ה-ב. Binyan was "Qal" for everything, nouns included.

shoresh-engine:
- Shoresh.Roots: an index over all of L1 (5853 verses, built once at
  server start, <1 s). A word resolves, in order: from the verse in
  scope (its own shoresh, with the binyan read from the verb's
  morphology; else its lemma's shoresh — לבבך → לבב); else the way Torah
  most often reads that surface form (its commonest lemma decides, so
  אשר the particle has no root); else a root the asker named, if Torah
  knows it. A word in the verse that L1 gives no root has none, whatever
  a homograph elsewhere carries. Unknown words yield nothing.
- Roots are rendered as L1 records them: two letters stay two letters.
- binyan is null unless a verb stands in the scoped verse.
- L1 is found via L1_MOUNT_POINT, not the literal l1/ relative to cwd —
  which is why parse_tree was null on the pod.
- Adds "surface" and "derivation" to each root (verse|lemma|torah|
  named_root). 22 new HSpec examples; 55 examples, 0 failures.

vav_pipeline:
- normalize_root places a lemma-derived root at the word it was heard
  from (L1 has no shoresh on לבבך to search by).
- A binyan is printed only where there is one; "binyan unknown" on a
  noun claimed a question that does not exist.
- test/tablet33_engine_roots_test.exs: the new shape through the router.
- liveness_test: clear a halt leaked by halt_monitor_test (the seed
  0/191243 flake, present since before tablet 30).
  461 tests, 0 failures on seeds 0 42 191243.

Verified before push with BOTH built images, the real engine binary and
a local PostgreSQL 16 (SSL): Devarim 6:5 → א-ה-ב (Qal, word 1), י-ה-ו,
א-ל-ה, כ-ל (words 5,7,9), ל-ב-ב, נ-פ-ש, מ-א-ד; 4 interpretations
written to L3, 0 L3_WRITE_FAILED, health healthy.

NOT repaired here: the quality of L1's own shoresh field, which the
engine is now faithful to — ויהי is recorded as יהי, שמים as שמ, יהוה
as יהו, הבאתי as בא. That is the quarry's tablet (scripts/build_l1.py)
and it changes the L1 hash; a decision, not a patch.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-04 17:28:08 +00:00

470 lines
18 KiB
Haskell
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
{-# LANGUAGE OverloadedStrings #-}
-- | Shoresh Engine test suite.
--
-- Tests the three Step 7 verification requirements:
-- 1. Root activation through all 7 binyanim
-- 2. Te'amim parse tree construction
-- 3. Gematria computation
--
-- Plus structural tests for types, lexicon, ketiv/qere, graph.
module Main where
import Test.Hspec
import qualified Data.Map.Strict as Map
import Data.Text (Text)
import Data.Maybe (isJust, isNothing, mapMaybe)
import Shoresh.Types
import Shoresh.Gematria
import Shoresh.Binyanim
import Shoresh.Teamim
import Shoresh.KetivQere
import Shoresh.Lexicon
import Shoresh.Graph
import Shoresh.Roots
import Shoresh.KiTov
import Luchot.Firmware
main :: IO ()
main = hspec $ do
consonantSpec
shoreshSpec
binyanSpec
gematriaSpec
teamimSpec
ketivQereSpec
graphSpec
kiTovSpec
firmwareSpec
rootsSpec
consonantSpec :: Spec
consonantSpec = describe "Consonant" $ do
it "has exactly 22 consonants" $
length [minBound .. maxBound :: Consonant] `shouldBe` 22
it "round-trips through char conversion" $ do
mapM_ (\c ->
charToConsonant (consonantToChar c) `shouldBe` Just c
) [minBound .. maxBound :: Consonant]
it "handles final forms (sofit)" $ do
charToConsonant 'ך' `shouldBe` Just Kaf
charToConsonant 'ם' `shouldBe` Just Mem
charToConsonant 'ן' `shouldBe` Just Nun
charToConsonant 'ף' `shouldBe` Just Pe
charToConsonant 'ץ' `shouldBe` Just Tsade
it "rejects non-Hebrew characters" $ do
charToConsonant 'a' `shouldBe` Nothing
charToConsonant '1' `shouldBe` Nothing
shoreshSpec :: Spec
shoreshSpec = describe "Shoresh" $ do
it "constructs a triliteral root" $ do
let sh = mkShoresh Bet Resh Aleph
c1 sh `shouldBe` Bet
c2 sh `shouldBe` Resh
c3 sh `shouldBe` Aleph
it "renders as Hebrew text" $ do
shoreshToText (mkShoresh Bet Resh Aleph) `shouldBe` "ברא"
shoreshToText (mkShoresh Qof Dalet Shin) `shouldBe` "קדש"
it "parses from Hebrew text (3 consonants)" $ do
textToShoresh "ברא" `shouldBe` Just (mkShoresh Bet Resh Aleph)
textToShoresh "קדש" `shouldBe` Just (mkShoresh Qof Dalet Shin)
it "parses from Hebrew text (2 consonants — biconsonantal)" $ do
-- Build log: some roots in L1 are 2-consonant (e.g. "שמ")
let result = textToShoresh "שמ"
result `shouldSatisfy` isJust
-- Bicons pad with He
case result of
Just sh -> c3 sh `shouldBe` He
Nothing -> expectationFailure "Should have parsed"
it "rejects invalid input" $ do
textToShoresh "" `shouldBe` Nothing
textToShoresh "א" `shouldBe` Nothing -- too short
textToShoresh "אבגד" `shouldBe` Nothing -- too long
binyanSpec :: Spec
binyanSpec = describe "Binyanim" $ do
it "has exactly 7 binyanim" $
length allBinyanim `shouldBe` 7
it "activates a root through all 7 binyanim" $ do
let sh = mkShoresh Bet Resh Aleph
let expanded = expand sh
Map.size expanded `shouldBe` 7
-- Each binyan should produce a peulah with the same root
mapM_ (\(b, p) -> root p `shouldBe` sh) (Map.toList expanded)
it "activate produces correct grammatical features" $ do
let sh = mkShoresh Shin Mem Resh -- שמר = guard
let p = activate Qal Third Singular Masculine Perfect sh
root p `shouldBe` sh
binyan p `shouldBe` Qal
person p `shouldBe` Third
number p `shouldBe` Singular
gender p `shouldBe` Masculine
aspect p `shouldBe` Perfect
it "activateDefault uses 3ms perfect citation form" $ do
let sh = mkShoresh Kaf Tav Bet -- כתב = write
let p = activateDefault Qal sh
person p `shouldBe` Third
number p `shouldBe` Singular
gender p `shouldBe` Masculine
aspect p `shouldBe` Perfect
gematriaSpec :: Spec
gematriaSpec = describe "Gematria" $ do
it "assigns correct values to individual letters" $ do
letterValue Aleph `shouldBe` 1
letterValue Yod `shouldBe` 10
letterValue Qof `shouldBe` 100
letterValue Tav `shouldBe` 400
it "computes root gematria correctly" $ do
-- ברא = Bet(2) + Resh(200) + Aleph(1) = 203
gematriaRoot (mkShoresh Bet Resh Aleph) `shouldBe` 203
-- קדש = Qof(100) + Dalet(4) + Shin(300) = 404
gematriaRoot (mkShoresh Qof Dalet Shin) `shouldBe` 404
-- שלם = Shin(300) + Lamed(30) + Mem(40) = 370
gematriaRoot (mkShoresh Shin Lamed Mem) `shouldBe` 370
it "computes word gematria correctly" $ do
-- תורה = Tav(400) + Vav(6) + Resh(200) + He(5) = 611
gematriaWord "תורה" `shouldBe` 611
-- שלום = Shin(300) + Lamed(30) + Vav(6) + Mem(40) = 376
gematriaWord "שלום" `shouldBe` 376
it "ignores non-consonant characters in word gematria" $ do
-- Word with vowels and cantillation should give same value
-- as consonants only
gematriaWord "בְּרֵאשִׁ֖ית" `shouldBe` gematriaWord "בראשית"
it "finds gematria neighbors" $ do
let bara = mkShoresh Bet Resh Aleph -- 203
let other = mkShoresh Resh Gimel Gimel -- 200+3+3 = 206, not 203
let lex = Map.fromList
[ (bara, ShoreshEntry bara Creation [] [] Map.empty)
, (other, ShoreshEntry other Creation [] [] Map.empty)
]
-- bara's neighbors at 203 should not include 'other' (206)
gematriaNeighbors 203 lex `shouldBe`
[ShoreshEntry bara Creation [] [] Map.empty]
teamimSpec :: Spec
teamimSpec = describe "Te'amim" $ do
it "classifies taam roles correctly" $ do
taamRole Etnachta `shouldBe` Melekh
taamRole SofPasuk `shouldBe` Melekh
taamRole Tipcha `shouldBe` Melekh
taamRole Munach `shouldBe` Mesharet
taamRole Mercha `shouldBe` Mesharet
it "parses taam names from L1 format" $ do
taamFromName "tipcha" `shouldBe` Just Tipcha
taamFromName "etnachta" `shouldBe` Just Etnachta
taamFromName "munach" `shouldBe` Just Munach
taamFromName "mercha" `shouldBe` Just Mercha
-- Build log correction #1: meteg_siluq
taamFromName "meteg_siluq" `shouldBe` Just MetegSiluq
it "ranks disjunctors by strength" $ do
taamRank SofPasuk `shouldSatisfy` (> taamRank Etnachta)
taamRank Etnachta `shouldSatisfy` (> taamRank ZakefKatan)
taamRank ZakefKatan `shouldSatisfy` (> taamRank Tipcha)
taamRank Tipcha `shouldSatisfy` (> taamRank Munach)
it "builds a parse tree from Bereishit 1:1 words" $ do
-- Bereishit 1:1: 7 words with these te'amim:
-- בראשית(tipcha) ברא(munach) אלהים(etnachta)
-- את(mercha) השמים(tipcha) ואת(mercha) הארץ(meteg_siluq)
let words =
[ AnnotatedWord "בְּרֵאשִׁ֖ית" Tipcha Melekh
, AnnotatedWord "בָּרָ֣א" Munach Mesharet
, AnnotatedWord "אֱלֹהִ֑ים" Etnachta Melekh
, AnnotatedWord "אֵ֥ת" Mercha Mesharet
, AnnotatedWord "הַשָּׁמַ֖יִם" Tipcha Melekh
, AnnotatedWord "וְאֵ֥ת" Mercha Mesharet
, AnnotatedWord "הָאָֽרֶץ" MetegSiluq Melekh
]
let tree = readTeamim words
-- The tree should exist and have branches
treeDepth tree `shouldSatisfy` (> 1)
it "finds primary division at etnachta" $ do
let words =
[ AnnotatedWord "בְּרֵאשִׁ֖ית" Tipcha Melekh
, AnnotatedWord "בָּרָ֣א" Munach Mesharet
, AnnotatedWord "אֱלֹהִ֑ים" Etnachta Melekh
, AnnotatedWord "אֵ֥ת" Mercha Mesharet
, AnnotatedWord "הַשָּׁמַ֖יִם" Tipcha Melekh
, AnnotatedWord "וְאֵ֥ת" Mercha Mesharet
, AnnotatedWord "הָאָֽרֶץ" MetegSiluq Melekh
]
let tree = readTeamim words
let (left, right) = primaryDivision tree
-- Left of etnachta should have: בראשית ברא אלהים
collectAllWords left `shouldBe`
["בְּרֵאשִׁ֖ית", "בָּרָ֣א", "אֱלֹהִ֑ים"]
-- Right of etnachta should have: את השמים ואת הארץ
collectAllWords right `shouldBe`
["אֵ֥ת", "הַשָּׁמַ֖יִם", "וְאֵ֥ת", "הָאָֽרֶץ"]
ketivQereSpec :: Spec
ketivQereSpec = describe "KetivQere" $ do
it "single reading returns same text for both" $ do
bothReadings (Single "שלום") `shouldBe` ("שלום", "שלום")
it "dual reading preserves both" $ do
let ref = Reference Bereishit 1 1
let dr = DualReading "הוא" "היא" ref
bothReadings (DualVal dr) `shouldBe` ("הוא", "היא")
it "isDual distinguishes correctly" $ do
isDual (Single "test") `shouldBe` False
isDual (DualVal (DualReading "a" "b" (Reference Bereishit 1 1))) `shouldBe` True
graphSpec :: Spec
graphSpec = describe "Graph" $ do
it "finds roots sharing 2 consonants" $ do
let bara = mkShoresh Bet Resh Aleph -- ברא
let barak = mkShoresh Bet Resh Kaf -- ברך (shares ב,ר)
let garaEnt = mkShoresh Gimel Resh Aleph -- גרא (shares ר,א)
let unrelated = mkShoresh Shin Lamed Mem -- שלם (shares nothing)
let lex = Map.fromList
[ (bara, ShoreshEntry bara Creation [] [] Map.empty)
, (barak, ShoreshEntry barak Blessing [] [] Map.empty)
, (garaEnt, ShoreshEntry garaEnt Movement [] [] Map.empty)
, (unrelated, ShoreshEntry unrelated Covenant [] [] Map.empty)
]
let ns = neighbors bara lex
length ns `shouldBe` 2 -- barak and gara, not unrelated
it "counts shared consonants correctly" $ do
let sh1 = mkShoresh Bet Resh Aleph
let sh2 = mkShoresh Bet Resh Kaf
sharedConsonants sh1 sh2 `shouldBe` 2
let sh3 = mkShoresh Shin Lamed Mem
sharedConsonants sh1 sh3 `shouldBe` 0
kiTovSpec :: Spec
kiTovSpec = describe "KiTov" $ do
it "returns Tov when all roots exist in lexicon" $ do
let sh = mkShoresh Bet Resh Aleph
let entry = ShoreshEntry sh Creation [] [Reference Bereishit 1 1] Map.empty
let lex = Map.fromList [(sh, entry)]
let result = ProcessedResult [] [entry]
kiTov result lex `shouldBe` Tov
it "returns LoTov when roots are missing" $ do
let sh = mkShoresh Bet Resh Aleph
let entry = ShoreshEntry sh Creation [] [Reference Bereishit 1 1] Map.empty
let emptyLex = Map.empty
let result = ProcessedResult [] [entry]
case kiTov result emptyLex of
LoTov _ -> return ()
other -> expectationFailure $ "Expected LoTov, got " ++ show other
firmwareSpec :: Spec
firmwareSpec = describe "Firmware" $ do
it "has correct L1 hash" $
l1ExpectedHash `shouldBe`
"99bbd07a5406e8acfc9d77ace277fe3e3ccee379a7fc4e48c61cc7c4ab7ea377"
it "has correct counts" $ do
torahBookCount `shouldBe` 5
torahVerseCount `shouldBe` 5853
torahWordCount `shouldBe` 79982
uniqueRootCount `shouldBe` 2608
it "dibrot exist" $
dibrot `shouldBe` Dibrot () () () () () () () () () ()
-- ============================================================
-- Roots — tablet 33: a word's root is what L1 records for it
-- ============================================================
-- | An L1 word as build_l1.py writes it (position, text and te'amim are
-- irrelevant to root resolution).
l1w :: Text -> Text -> Text -> Maybe Text -> L1Word
l1w cons lemma morph sh = L1Word
{ l1wPosition = 0, l1wText = cons, l1wConsonants = cons, l1wLemma = lemma
, l1wMorph = morph, l1wTeamim = [], l1wPrefix = Nothing, l1wShoresh = sh }
l1v :: Text -> Int -> Int -> [L1Word] -> L1Verse
l1v book ch vs ws = L1Verse
{ l1vRef = "", l1vBook = book, l1vChapter = ch, l1vVerse = vs
, l1vTextHebrew = "", l1vWords = ws }
-- Devarim 6:5, as L1 holds it: three suffixed nouns carry no shoresh.
devarim65 :: L1Verse
devarim65 = l1v "devarim" 6 5
[ l1w "ואהבת" "157" "HC/Vqq2ms" (Just "אהב")
, l1w "את" "853" "HTo" Nothing
, l1w "יהוה" "3068" "HNp" (Just "יהו")
, l1w "אלהיך" "430" "HNcmpc/Sp2ms" Nothing
, l1w "בכל" "3605" "HR/Ncmsc" (Just "כל")
, l1w "לבבך" "3824" "HNcmsc/Sp2ms" Nothing
, l1w "ובכל" "3605" "HC/R/Ncmsc" (Just "כל")
, l1w "נפשך" "5315" "HNcbsc/Sp2ms" Nothing
]
-- Elsewhere in Torah: the same lemmas with a shoresh of their own.
elsewhere :: [L1Verse]
elsewhere =
[ l1v "bereishit" 1 1
[ l1w "בראשית" "7225" "HR/Ncfsa" (Just "ראש")
, l1w "ברא" "1254" "HVqp3ms" (Just "ברא")
, l1w "אלהים" "430" "HNcmpa" (Just "אלה")
, l1w "את" "853" "HTo" Nothing
]
, l1v "bereishit" 1 3
[ l1w "ויאמר" "559" "HC/Vqw3ms" (Just "אמר")
, l1w "אור" "216" "HNcbsa" (Just "אור")
, l1w "ויהי־אור" "1961" "HC/Vqw3ms" (Just "יהי")
]
, l1v "bereishit" 1 4
[ l1w "ויבדל" "914" "HC/Vhw3ms" (Just "בדל") ]
, l1v "devarim" 4 29
[ l1w "לבב" "3824" "HNcmsa" (Just "לבב")
, l1w "נפש" "5315" "HNcbsa" (Just "נפש")
]
-- Homographs. אשר: the relative particle twice, the name Asher once.
-- את: the object marker everywhere, but אתה yields the root את.
, l1v "shemot" 3 14
[ l1w "אשר" "834 a" "HTr" Nothing
, l1w "אהיה" "1961" "HVqi1cs" (Just "היה")
, l1w "אשר" "834 a" "HTr" Nothing
]
, l1v "bereishit" 30 13
[ l1w "אשר" "836" "HNp" (Just "אשר")
, l1w "אתה" "859 a" "HPp2ms" (Just "את")
]
]
testIndex :: RootIndex
testIndex = buildIndex (devarim65 : elsewhere)
shoreshim :: [ResolvedRoot] -> [Text]
shoreshim = map rrShoresh
rootsSpec :: Spec
rootsSpec = describe "Roots (tablet 33)" $ do
describe "what the old engine did, and must not do again" $ do
it "a particle is not a root — את yields nothing, never א-ת-ה" $
resolveText testIndex Nothing "את" `shouldBe` []
it "a three-letter word is not a root because it has three letters" $
-- בכל was reported as ב-כ-ל; L1 says its root is כל.
shoreshim (resolveText testIndex (Just devarim65) "בכל") `shouldBe` ["כל"]
it "a long word is not dropped — ויאמר is א-מ-ר" $
shoreshim (resolveText testIndex Nothing "ויאמר") `shouldBe` ["אמר"]
it "a word Torah does not contain yields nothing" $
resolveText testIndex Nothing "מחשב" `shouldBe` []
it "non-Hebrew input yields nothing" $
resolveText testIndex Nothing "Test query 1" `shouldBe` []
describe "the whole of Devarim 6:5" $ do
let roots = resolveText testIndex (Just devarim65)
"ואהבת את יהוה אלהיך בכל לבבך ובכל נפשך"
it "finds א-ה-ב, and the heart and the soul" $
shoreshim roots `shouldBe` ["אהב", "יהו", "אלה", "כל", "לבב", "נפש"]
it "a word in the verse with its own shoresh is heard from the verse" $
map rrDerivation (take 2 roots) `shouldBe` [FromVerse, FromVerse]
it "a suffixed noun with no shoresh is heard through its lemma" $
[ rrDerivation r | r <- roots, rrShoresh r `elem` ["לבב", "נפש", "אלה"] ]
`shouldBe` [FromLemma, FromLemma, FromLemma]
it "כל appears once though the verse says it twice" $
length (filter (== "כל") (shoreshim roots)) `shouldBe` 1
describe "binyan" $ do
it "is read from the verb's morphology in the verse" $ do
let v = elsewhere !! 2
map rrBinyan (resolveText testIndex (Just v) "ויבדל") `shouldBe` [Just Hifil]
map rrBinyan (resolveText testIndex (Just devarim65) "ואהבת") `shouldBe` [Just Qal]
it "is not claimed for a noun" $
map rrBinyan (resolveText testIndex (Just devarim65) "בכל") `shouldBe` [Nothing]
it "is not claimed for a word outside the verse in scope" $
map rrBinyan (resolveText testIndex (Just devarim65) "ויבדל") `shouldBe` [Nothing]
it "parses OSHB stems" $ do
binyanFromMorph "HC/Vqw3ms" `shouldBe` Just Qal
binyanFromMorph "HVhp1cs" `shouldBe` Just Hifil
binyanFromMorph "HVNp3ms" `shouldBe` Just Nifal
binyanFromMorph "HVtw3ms" `shouldBe` Just Hitpael
binyanFromMorph "HNcmsa" `shouldBe` Nothing
describe "homographs" $ do
it "a particle in the verse has no root, though Torah knows את as a root" $ do
resolveText testIndex (Just devarim65) "את" `shouldBe` []
resolveText testIndex Nothing "את" `shouldBe` []
it "out of scope, a word is read the way Torah most often reads it" $
-- אשר: particle ×2, the name ×1. The particle wins; no root.
resolveText testIndex Nothing "אשר" `shouldBe` []
it "in scope, the verse decides — אשר the particle in Shemot 3:14" $
shoreshim (resolveText testIndex (Just (elsewhere !! 4)) "אהיה אשר אהיה")
`shouldBe` ["היה"]
describe "other ways a root is heard" $ do
it "from elsewhere in Torah when the word is not in the verse in scope" $
map (\r -> (rrShoresh r, rrDerivation r))
(resolveText testIndex (Just devarim65) "ויאמר")
`shouldBe` [("אמר", FromTorah)]
it "a root the asker names, if Torah knows it as a root" $
map (\r -> (rrShoresh r, rrDerivation r)) (resolveText testIndex Nothing "אמר")
`shouldBe` [("אמר", NamedRoot)]
it "a three-letter string Torah does not know as a root is not one" $
resolveText testIndex Nothing "קטל" `shouldBe` []
describe "tokenize" $ do
it "strips nikud and te'amim" $
tokenize "וַיֹּ֥אמֶר אֱלֹהִ֖ים" `shouldBe` ["ויאמר", "אלהים"]
it "splits maqaf before stripping marks (tablet 30a)" $
tokenize "וַֽיְהִי־אֽוֹר ׃" `shouldBe` ["ויהי", "אור"]
it "indexes both halves of a maqaf-joined L1 word" $
shoreshim (resolveText testIndex Nothing "ויהי") `shouldBe` ["יהי"]
-- ============================================================
-- Helpers
-- ============================================================
treeDepth :: ParsedVerse -> Int
treeDepth (Leaf _) = 1
treeDepth (Branch _ l r) = 1 + max (treeDepth l) (treeDepth r)
collectAllWords :: ParsedVerse -> [Text]
collectAllWords (Leaf w) = [awWord w]
collectAllWords (Branch _ l r) = collectAllWords l ++ collectAllWords r